Fat Tomato

Outstanding pizza! This place has been flying under the radar...it's so good! Thin crust, NY style, solid undercarriage, crispy, no flop, and full of flavor. Homemade meatballs and quality pepperoni. They had homemade Tiramisu and Cheesecake that was out of this world! Put this place on your map!

I Beg for everybody to try this place out you owe it to yourself. This is in my top two pizza places of all time And I’ve tried a lot of pizza. The owner is just a nice dude that loves making pizza and let me tell you he does it right. Nowhere else in the state, let alone Holyoke even comes close this pizza I promise. Just look at this photo, where else is making you something that even looks close to this good. And trust me it taste even better than it looks. I have ordered from this place now…

Amazing pizza! Simply put, one the best I've had in years. Beyond any expectations we had. Definitely 💯 going back for another butchers pie! Perfect under carriage and cooked to perfection . Youll be very surprised by how delicious and crispy the crust is and how fresh the toppings were. 🍕💚😎♥️👈✅💯🤙

This is hands down the best pizza in Massachusetts, maybe the best pizza anywhere. I moved from Phoenix about 4 years ago and was missing my favorite pizza spot until I found Fat Tomato, which quickly became my new favorite pizza spot. Now I am kind of addicted and have to get a Tuscan Roni at least once a month. I agree with all the other reviews about how fresh the ingredients are—they use really good quality ingredients and it makes such a difference. Also, the owner was kind enough to give…

My family loves Fat Tomato. Everything is made so fresh and you can taste it. Quality ingredients make this place different. We chose Fat Tomato over all the other local pizza places. We love the Crime Scene, Tour of Italy, and the Margherita pizza. The cannolis are made fresh every day!