Schermerhorn's Seafood

We had a great lunch at Schermerhorn’s Seafood! We ordered the Fisherman’s Platter and the chicken sandwich, and everything was delicious. The food was fresh, hot, and cooked perfectly. The newly renovated restaurant is beautiful inside—very clean, bright, and welcoming. They did an amazing job bringing this longtime Holyoke landmark back to life. The staff were all very friendly, and the service was excellent. After lunch, we stopped at the attached ice cream shop for dessert, which was the…

We had a business lunch and were pleasantly surprised with the atmosphere. The restaurant has a very comfortable feel, and the bar itself is very impressive. We had two orders of fish and chips, one baked scrod, and a chicken sandwich. The sandwich was a little disappointing for the person who had it, but admitted, well, this is a seafood place. We also shared calamari which was very good. I will be going back for dinner in the near future.

We just had lunch here and the service from Ally was exceptional! The food was 10 out of 10 perfection! I’m hoping they keep the stuffed mushrooms because they definitely were our favorite! Highly recommend checking them out!!

Overall we really enjoyed the time here! Servers and hosts were AMAZING, drinks were tasty. Just a couple small things of note. App: we had the Tuna Poke martini as our app. Flavors were great, but the temperature was a little warm for my liking. It should have been very chilled, instead, it was just below room temp. And the avocado had clearly been out for a half hour or so; it was brown. But again, flavor wise (esp the wasabi cream!) was good. My fish tacos were good, although I wish there…

Our server was amazing. I think her name was Brightly or something like that. The food was scrumptious. I had the fisherman's platter. There was so much food, enough for two. Everything was fresh and hot. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.